I know there’s been much ado about the owner of Abercrombie and Fitch criticizing ugly people while many here consider him to be ugly. I could go on about whether this is or isn’t hypocritical on either front and about the subjective meaning of beauty and all that but I want to address something I feel is more important and that’s the comparison of the man in question to an orc.
Most of the memes resulting from this controversy have shown Gothmog alongside their C.E.O., and I want to talk about why that’s wrong.
Gothmog served in Sauron’s army during the War of the Ring, as the lieutenant of Minas Morgul, second-in-command to the Witch-king of Angmar, lord of the nine Nazgûl. He took command of the forces of Morgul during the Battle of the Pelennor Fields after the Witch-king was slain by Éowyn. That makes him a veteran and I don’t care what side he fought for, the point is he fought for what he believed in and did so with exceptional nobility. It was he who called for Grond to break down the gates of Minas Tirith, it was he who was nearly crushed when the white city launched chunks of massive stone on his location, moving only at the final moment to survive. All with a tumor on his head the size of a grapefruit. And tumblr has made him the standard of ugliness.
I don’t give a damn about Abercrombie guy, but to reduce one of if not the greatest of orcs to an ugly joke just to mock the guy in unfair and ignorant.

I know there’s been much ado about the owner of Abercrombie and Fitch criticizing ugly people while many here consider him to be ugly. I could go on about whether this is or isn’t hypocritical on either front and about the subjective meaning of beauty and all that but I want to address something I feel is more important and that’s the comparison of the man in question to an orc.

Most of the memes resulting from this controversy have shown Gothmog alongside their C.E.O., and I want to talk about why that’s wrong.

Gothmog served in Sauron’s army during the War of the Ring, as the lieutenant of Minas Morgul, second-in-command to the Witch-king of Angmar, lord of the nine Nazgûl. He took command of the forces of Morgul during the Battle of the Pelennor Fields after the Witch-king was slain by Éowyn. That makes him a veteran and I don’t care what side he fought for, the point is he fought for what he believed in and did so with exceptional nobility. It was he who called for Grond to break down the gates of Minas Tirith, it was he who was nearly crushed when the white city launched chunks of massive stone on his location, moving only at the final moment to survive. All with a tumor on his head the size of a grapefruit. And tumblr has made him the standard of ugliness.

I don’t give a damn about Abercrombie guy, but to reduce one of if not the greatest of orcs to an ugly joke just to mock the guy in unfair and ignorant.

@1 year ago with 8483 notes
#abercrombie & fitch #abercrombie #orc #lotr #gothmog 
  1. renacc reblogged this from seasonally-me
  2. thetallestofhobbits reblogged this from ianthe and added:
    Oh, Tolkien fandom. You are such wonderful scholars and people.
  3. jessahkat reblogged this from seasonally-me
  4. seasonally-me reblogged this from ianthe
  5. nosirnihilismisntpractical reblogged this from ianthe
  6. the-optimistic-rose reblogged this from sharkchunks
  7. melkorsrighthand reblogged this from charliewomanofletters
  8. senor-cluckens reblogged this from facts-i-just-made-up
  9. trekkie8472 reblogged this from sharkchunks and added:
    Reblogging this again as a response to my last reblog.
  10. captain-curbstomp reblogged this from agameofcharades
  11. agameofcharades reblogged this from charadesarchive
  12. releasetheprisoners reblogged this from sharkchunks
  13. timesnewtrojan reblogged this from ianthe
  14. luuklsl reblogged this from kindoftiredd
  15. nice-butt-mirror reblogged this from kindoftiredd
  16. kindoftiredd reblogged this from ianthe
  17. srsly-dude-srsly reblogged this from ianthe
  18. anonymous-dudette reblogged this from ianthe
  19. thesaviorcomplex reblogged this from frankensoul
  20. frankensoul reblogged this from ianthe
  21. slightlyamusedslightlyannoyed reblogged this from rabbitzfeet
  22. rabbitzfeet reblogged this from zombievangelion
  23. tylermanymules reblogged this from sharkchunks
  24. robinboywonder219 reblogged this from sharkchunks
  25. just-a-girl-lost-in-the-world reblogged this from the-peanut-gallery